Notebook vs. Desktop PC: Small Fry Takes on Big Guy
CLOVERDALE,
CA - May 14, 2002 -
Worldwide shipments of notebook computers will increase by 15.8% annually, growing from
35 million units in 2001 to over 73 million units in 2005. Over the same time
period worldwide shipments of desktop PCs will grow at an annual rate of 7.8%,
roughly half
that of notebooks. By 2005 notebooks will account for about 30% of the desktop
PC and notebook market, up from 21% in 2002.

Gains in notebook sales over desktop PCs result primarily from increased
functionality (more efficient chips and wireless networking) and price
(in the $1000 range for low-end models). While notebook sales
are at the expense of desktop PCs, the buying trend toward
notebooks does not signal
the demise of desktop PCs. Consider the following comparison of features and attributes
between the two:
-
Performance: Advantage,
desktop PCs.
However, notebook processing speed and memory are sufficient for most
corporate and home users.
-
Keyboard/pointing device:
Advantage, desktop PCs. Keyboards for desktop PCs are easier to use. Notebook keyboards are cramped. Given the choice, most
people prefer a mouse over a touch pad. A full-size keyboard and mouse require
a docking station on most notebooks, an added expense.
-
Monitor: Advantage, desktop
PCs. Desktop PCs offer a wider range of screen sizes and resolution. The
resolution of notebook screens has improved greatly, but in order to be truly
portable, notebook screens greater than 15" will be impractical.
-
Peripherals: Advantage,
desktop PCs,
but nearly a draw. Most peripherals use USB (or FireWire) and any number
of peripherals can be attached to a notebook or desktop PC.
-
Docking station: Advantage,
desktop PCs. The desktop PC wins hands down—docking
station not required for
peripherals, monitor, keyboard, or pointing devices.
-
Theft/damage/wear and tear:
Advantage, desktop PCs. Notebooks are far easier to steal. You're also more
likely to drop, spill coffee on....a notebook. Notebooks also suffer travel
induced wear and tear.
-
Portability: Advantage, notebooks—their reason for being.
-
Cost: Per given memory and
speed desktop PCs are less
expensive than notebooks, generally $150 to $300 dollars for similar
functionality. If you want a 15" screen on a
notebook add
$150. To make a notebook a truly functional desktop PC, add
a docking station ($150-$300),
keyboard and mouse ($50) and external monitor ($200+).
While the line between
functionality of desktop PCs and notebooks blurs, desktop PCs will maintain a significant cost
advantage over notebooks.
The
information in this
In-Depth Analysis is based on a review of the InfoTech Trends
database of market research statistics, as well as additional sources. For more
market data on the information technology industry, go to
Free Data.
|
|